Customer Reviews:
 Great for my GPS May 30, 2007
5 out of 5 found this review helpful
I bought this software mainly for use onscreen on my new 60CSX GPS, and so far it's been great for that. I've also sampled some of the trip planning features on my laptop, and that's worked out well, too. My only compliant is that the back roads aren't labeled on my GPS screen, so it makes it hard when I'm driving and want to know quickly what road I'm looking at, but the routes are pretty accurate, so I can usually identify by that. Also, some of the data is out of date for those remote roads. I've found a couple so far that are listed as roads, but have been converted to hiking trails, or reverted to elk trails, many years ago. Coupled with a more detailed (and sometimes more recent, though not always) Forest Service map, it's just fine. Well worth it for adding detail to your onscreen GPS maps.
 Works like is is supposed to May 28, 2007
4 out of 4 found this review helpful
I love this product. First copy this disk to your hard disk, and then install from there. Then you don't have to used the CD each time you load the MapSource application. Also be sure to download the latest version of MapSource from Garmin after you install the CD version.
 Not there yet May 25, 2007
4 out of 4 found this review helpful
I've just spent the last two days trying to get this program and my new 60 Csx working and must agree with some of the negative comments here. The installation manual and user support are the minimum necessary if your computer, your GPS, and the software all work in harmony. Any glitches, and you will probably have glitches, you will find yourself in agreement with the negative posters here. You would think that with a this keystone product Garmin would write a manual that deals with it specifically; instead what you get is a vague description of how things should work for all Garmin products. With nothing specific to this map set it is impossible to troubleshoot.
Some posters here have been happy with the level of detail and have suggested that those who are dissatisfied are either unaware of how to use the product or unrealistic about what a 1:100000 map can provide. Perhaps the maps are better for regions I haven't looked at, but on the highest level of detail for Wisconsin I found the map inferior to what I could have drawn from memory. There are also many errors in an area that hasn't changed much over the last thirty years. My suggestion: if you like me are hoping for a major GPS upgrade from a first generation unit wait for the software to catch up. If you are just starting out buy an inexpensive unit and bring good paper maps along. Here's hoping apple gets into GPS.
Great map set May 14, 2007
3 out of 4 found this review helpful
Basically, what you would expect in a 1:24K topo set. The thing to be aware of is that these are topo maps, not trail maps, although they do seem to have a lot of the major trails on them. I'm using them to plan a trip to four national parks this fall.
One notable feature of this set is that it can be installed 100% onto the computer hard drive without jumping through any hoops. So, once you have installed the maps, you can put the CDs away for safekeeping.
Rough Around the Edges April 25, 2007
10 out of 10 found this review helpful
MapSource USA Topo has all the features needed to be a fine product. The maps I thought were of decent quality, and included some nicities I didn't necessarily expect, like more detailed roadways than the base map my Garmin GPS came with. It's abilities to send data to and from the GPS, along with what could be done with that data, were sufficient and useful. All in all, a very useful product.
However, despite it's advantages, I encountered numerous problems during the installation and while trying to use it. For starters, the user manual is almost useless when it comes to installation. It was written in a somewhat vague and imcomplete way in an attempt to cover the installation steps for multiple different MapSource products. During initial install, it wanted to check for the GPS, but it could not find it, prompting me to select a serial COM port, despite that I was using a USB connection. However, once installed, it saw the GPS without any problems. It also did not appear to have any custom installation options. Only "Typical Installation" was available as an option during the install. The maps are stored on 3 separate disks that were not copied to the hard drive as I would have liked. When I switch between east or west US, I am forced to switch disks. I assume there is a way to fully install the maps to the hard drive, but I have yet to figure it out. I would have expected it to be part of a "Custom Installation" option that it didn't seem to have.
Installed, If I attempt to use the Unlock Maps feature, it results in an error saying that it couldn't start the UnlockWizard and suggesting a reinstall of the application. And the grand daddy of errors that you should never see in a product, selecting "Check for Updates" from the Help menu results in a fatal error.
Finally, the product seperation and versioning is confusing. It is difficult to tell what parts of the software are from USA Topo versus what parts are from other installed MapSource pieces, as they all get blurred into one. This also makes the versions confusing, as looking at the version in the Help menu shows a different version than what is seen on the software packaging.
All of these problems make me very wary of what would otherwise be a fine product. If they can refine it to where it is more user friendly and error free, I would recommend it. But until then, I would only cautiously recommend it to the computer savvy who are used to dealing with random errors and working around them.
|
