|
| 
 enlarge | Author: Barbara Ehrenreich
Publisher: Holt Paperbacks
Category: Book
List Price: $13.00
Buy Used: $0.86
You Save: $12.14 (93%)
New (121) Used (1219) Collectible (20) from $0.86
Rating:  1086 reviews
Sales Rank: 2899
Media: Paperback
Number Of Items: 1
Pages: 240
Shipping Weight (lbs): 0.4
Dimensions (in): 8 x 5.4 x 0.7
ISBN: 0805063897
Dewey Decimal Number: 305.569092
EAN: 9780805063899
ASIN: 0805063897
Publication Date: May 1, 2002
Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days
Shipping: Expedited shipping available
Shipping: International shipping available
Condition: With pride from Motor City. All books guaranteed. Best Service, best prices.
|
| Customer Reviews:
 Royalties are more than a nickel or a dime May 1, 2008
2 out of 6 found this review helpful
One reason I am uncomfortable with some people in the publishing industry is that I am from a different class than they are. And I don't mean that the way people might think.
Only somebody very self-satisfied with her own status, socially, intellectually and economically, would have written this book in the manner it is written. Many readers, particularly the tens of thousands of college sociology or first-year English students to whom the book is assigned, won't get how ironic and insulting the introduction is (if they read it). There's simply no way to make one of these insider publisher lunches sound like anything other than what it is, a greedy conversation about ego and money. The project, and the book, begins with an arrogant and condescending scheme made to sound somehow "brave" or "noble" -- but only in the eyes of somebody who'd consider working at WalMart, as a waitress at Dennys, or as a cleaning person to be a terrifying prospect. Think about that -- somebody does have to work at WalMart. We can't eat at Dennys if nobody waits tables there. People are willing to pay to have their houses cleaned and it is work that many have done over the years to support themselves and their families.
Bottom line, this author is far too self-satisfied, and has the typical successful "author's ego," to write an effective book about real people who are struggling to get by. It doesn't matter what she says. This book was meant to espouse a political philosophy, and it was meant to embarrass major corporations or even small employers who treat and pay their employees poorly. In the process it made all of the people covered into ciphers - often she didn't even bother to mention the people's names and seldom got into too many details about her co-workers. It's unwise to humanize people, I guess - but I know better.
I am a writer. It's clear that this author can't humanize the people who truly work at these low-wage jobs, because it isn't in her. To this author, "ideas" and "political convictions" are more important than people.
And that is the value discussion here. Students are largely taught that political decisions will solve people's problems. They are told to read this book, despite the fact that the author can barely be bothered to name many of her co-workers, and as the book goes on, is less- and less- interested in them than in documenting the little slights she endured along the way, and minor hardships (pee in a cup, take stupid test, get treated like you might steal the merchandise, hurt feet, walking to/from work - IMAGINE THAT!).
A better book for students to read to make them think about values, culture, and materialism is Into the Wild, by Jon Krakauer. That story, by a writer of infinitely more insight, talent and empathy, telling about the amazing journey and thoughts of Christopher McCandless, will give a different view of the world.
This is the basic circumstance: When people give up control of their minds and lives to any ideology, they lose the most precious things they have: their individuality and right to self-determination. It is not that WalMart (Dennys, Merry Maids, etc.) are, or are not evil and must be shut down and combated. If you truly think your life-purpose is best-served by ranting against any big corporation, or if you think "political philosophy" takes the place of experiencing life, then what have you learned? In which world can you name any activity where you appreciate and have benefited from any outside organization (government, employer) telling you what to do and how to do it? At best, there are things where we all know we need to follow the same rules if we want to participate.
I think this book is actively harmful to people working at lower-wage jobs. I think it dehumanizes them and uses them as pawns. The complaints of the author about her own issues such as peeing in a cup or having an insensitive boss who didn't care whether she was at work or not, are so trivial compared to -- victims of crime, victims of sexual harassment, the laid-off, the injured-on-the-job, and so-on.
But that's the thing, isn't it? That is a value system. Where every individual person is dehumanized except the powerful person trying to tell others' what to say, think or so.
Think for yourself. Don't take your "wisdom" from an arrogant semi-intellectual who couldn't even spend 3 weeks on any one of these jobs before quitting.
 Good Book for those thinking about college April 27, 2008
0 out of 2 found this review helpful
I think that this book is a must reead for those who are trying figure out if they should go to college or not. It give a very good picture of how it really is when you do not have higher education.
Good Message, Bad Tone April 15, 2008
1 out of 4 found this review helpful
Barbara Ehrenreich took on the ambitious task of going undercover as a low-wage worker. She wrote this book to explain how people who work for minimum wage get by in America. However, I found this book to be unrealistic, anecdotal, and pessimistic.
Barbara Ehrenreich is an acclaimed writer for her books and articles in magazines such as Time and The New Republic. She got the idea for this book during lunch with her editor. They were wondering how people could live on minimum wage, and they decided that going undercover would be a good way to answer the question.
The first job that Barbara took on was as a waitress in Florida. She received just $2.43 an hour plus tips, and she found it very hard to live. She took on two jobs for a short period of time, but she had to drop one because it was extremely physically taxing. She got overwhelmed with keeping up rent, and one day, she got up and left for Maine. In Maine, she worked as a housekeeper on weekdays and at a nursing home during the weekends. The housing situation was probably the best here, but she had to work hard to make a living. As a housekeeper, she was constantly in pain and undergoing strenuous work. One woman who was pregnant and had a broken ankle had to continue working so she could have a roof over her head. The management in Maine disgusted Barbara. Barbara also worked at Wal-Mart in Minnesota, and she found the working conditions to be very poor. The housing situation was very difficult in the region, and Barbara quit when she couldn't find an apartment.
This book really helped me to value the importance of education and acknowledged the problems with low-wage jobs. On the other hand, I do not think that the author accomplished the initial point of her book. Barbara used a lot of sarcasm and had a pessimistic tone often in the book. She focused more on the poor quality of her jobs, rather than the economic aspects and how she financially made a living. Her tone can be taken as offensive in some parts of the book, especially when she made references to religion and abortion, which are both sensitive topics to many. Overall, the book was a good idea, and had a good message, but the tone in which it was written was not satisfactory.
Compelling and Maddening April 13, 2008
2 out of 3 found this review helpful
This book has a very promising premise, one that many middle- or upper-class people living in the United States never examine: what life is like for those trying to survive on minimum-wage salaries. The author travels from city to city, going through the process of trying to put down roots, and dealing with the difficulty in starting a new life, wrestling especially with the question of how to get a job without a permanent address, and how to find affordable housing when she doesn't yet have a paycheck.
Quickly the author learns that it is nearly impossible for her to survive anywhere on a single job, yet she also finds out that she simply doesn't have the necessary stamina to work more than one job at a time. It is furthermore a nightmare of scheduling to try to find two jobs that don't overlap their hours.
I found this book maddening; I was infuriated at the fact that those working the jobs alongside the author couldn't seem to get ahead, and the ways in which they were taken advantage of by their employers, as in the withholding of a first paycheck from the employees who desperately needed that money for rent or food.
The other maddening part of this book was the fact that there didn't seem to be any solution to this problem of poverty. I was left with an overwhelming feeling of helplessness on finishing this book, horrified at the thought that so many people are living in such dire circumstances, one step away from homelessness and hunger.
Although the author is up-front about the fact that her experience won't be truly authentic, in that she has financial and social resources to fall back on in her real life, I was put off by the fact that she would smoke marijuana shortly before applying for jobs she should have known would require a drug test. With all of the other comforts she was willing to give up for her story, it seems like she would have refrained from this behavior that had the potential to completely sabotage her experiment.
Overall, this book gave me a great deal to think about, and made me appreciate my relative financial security all the more.
An Insight into the real "working world" April 4, 2008
3 out of 4 found this review helpful
Nickel and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America is one of the best books I have read in a long time. It is very eloquently written and is easy to become enthralled with. Personally, I am hard to please in the world of published literature but when I sat down to read this book, I found myself not wanting to stop. The way Ehrenreich conveys the world of minimum wage really gives the reader a good understanding of their lives. When reading, it is inevitable that one is overcome with a feeling of intense empathy for the characters of the book. Not only is this book interesting to read but, it is full of information that is relevant in today's society, especially with the economic crisis. After reading this book, I find it hard to go to a resturaunt or hotel without thinking about the strenuous labor that the hundreds of workers put in to make many of our middle to upper class lives an ounce better. Ehrenreich's brave step into what seems like another world was a step that needed to be taken. From her hardships and experiences we can learn a lot. Everyone could benefit from reading this book. I give it 4 stars.
|
|
|
The Outpost Network | |
